In a world where musicals often strive for uniqueness, Bank of Dave: The Musical presents an intriguing paradox. It's a show that seems desperately eager to please, yet it boasts a likable and inspiring true story at its core. The question arises: why does this musical feel so insecure about its appeal?
The Insecurity Paradox
The pre-show introduction sets the tone, assuming an audience unfamiliar with theater and harboring a deep-seated dislike for bankers. This assumption is further reinforced by the excessive pop culture references scattered throughout Rob Madge's book. It's as if the musical is shouting, "We're one of you! We get your references!"
What makes this particularly fascinating is the underlying message it sends. By assuming a lack of sophistication in its audience, the musical inadvertently creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. It almost seems to be saying, "If you don't understand these references, you're not the target audience."
A Feel-Good Story with a Twist
The source material, a true story of Dave Fishwick, is a heartwarming tale of a businessman with a conscience. Fishwick's journey to establish a non-profit bank, driven by a desire to empower his community, is a David and Goliath narrative with a happy ending. This story, when fictionalized for the Netflix film, already had the makings of a compelling musical.
However, the musical takes a different approach. It presents itself as a community-driven show, with a romantic subplot adding a layer of complexity. The director, Nikolai Foster, crafts an energetic production, with a set that constantly erupts into large chorus numbers. The songs, composed by Pippa Cleary, draw from a diverse range of genres, adding to the overall cheerfulness of the show.
Honesty and Authenticity
One of the standout features of Bank of Dave: The Musical is its honesty. It acknowledges the north-south divide, even apologizing for the "southern saviour narrative." The characters, while flirting with clichés, are presented with a certain authenticity. The show doesn't shy away from addressing inequality and the possibility of change, making it a down-to-earth and relatable production.
Deeper Analysis
The musical's insecurity, as reflected in its excessive references, might be a strategic move to appeal to a broader audience. By assuming a lack of knowledge, it aims to include rather than exclude. This strategy, while risky, could pay off by attracting a diverse range of theatergoers.
Conclusion
Bank of Dave: The Musical is a testament to the power of storytelling and community. It's a show that, despite its insecurities, manages to captivate and inspire. The true story at its heart, combined with a talented cast and creative team, makes for an enjoyable and thought-provoking experience. It's a reminder that sometimes, the most likable shows are those that dare to be themselves, insecurities and all.
